Dear Friend,
It has been a while since we last spoke.
During this time I have been wondering how best to get things kick
started.
The most effective medium that I found was using the Right To
Information Act.
I have used this Act four times so far and I would like to outline
below what I did.
First Instance of using RTI:
We have a "bad" neighbour who is very argumentative and she kept
collecting dry leaves from her garden and burning them every ten
days or so. When we told her to stop this practice she initially
said that she had "taken permission" from the corporation.
Subsequently, she became defiant and told us to "do whatever we
wished to". We did two things. (a) We went to the Police station and
made a complaint. Contrary to our perception that the police are
sluggish, they were at the spot within ten minutes and they
counselled her that she should not burn the leaves but dispose off
them by giving them to the corporation workers every morning for
removal. (b) we made an RTI application to the Corporation stating
the facts of the matter and asking them whether this was permissible
etc. With 3 days two Corporation people went to see her. They told
her not to burn leaves and in addition, took a letter from her
stating that she would not burn the leaves in future.
Second Instance of using RTI:
We have another neighbour who has a noisy dog. The dog barks from
5.30 am till 11.30 pm almost non stop. Though a very good pedigree
dog, the neighbours ill treat it by keeping it constantly locked up,
forget to feed it food (it starts barking continuously at food time
to remind them to feed it) etc. Rather than make a complaint, I
decided to make a RTI application to the police. When I went to the
police station, the constable on duty at the desk was not even aware
about RTI! I waited a few minutes and then saw the Sub-Inspector and
asked him who the Public Information Officer was. Initially he tried
to persuade me (a) that his Police Station was not the place to
submit the RTI application but that I should submit it to a senior
officer and (b) that instead of an RTI application, I could just
submit a complaint. I was firm re submitting the RTI aplication and
he accepted it, signing the copy and affixing his rubber stamp to
it. Within 4 days, a police constable went to the neighbour's house.
I do not know what transpired but I can see a visible improvement in
the treatment of the dog. Its barking has also come down
substantially.
Third use of RTI:
The corporation cleaners who used to remove garbage from our
premises stopped doing so and became erratic in their duties. They
took the stand that they would only remove household garbage and not
remove the leaves that fall from the plants and trees. Within 48
hours of a RTI application being submitted, the local JE met us and
apologized for the inconvenience caused to us. From that day on, our
whole road's garbage gets very efficiently cleared.
Fourth use of RTI:
I have an account with Indian Overseas Bank. The Jayanagar branch
has extremely inefficient people who think that they are doing a big
favour by dealing with their own customers. I saw some strange
entries in my passbook. One of them read:
VID-7301- 8997-0-1 1.00
With the above entry they had deducted Re 1 from my account.
Just imagine what would happen if Indian Overseas bank deducted Re 1
from each of the millions of people who have accounts with them: (a)
they would be richer by millions and almost everyone would say "It's
only a Rupee, why bother".
There was another instance where they multiple charged me for a
debit card purchase done at a medical store. Whereas I had made one
purchase for Rs. 130, they debited me three times and credited me
once for the same purchase. Enquiries with the local branch resulted
in "make a complaint addressed to our manager; we will check and get
back to you". They never got back to me. I therefore decided to make
a RTI complaint to the bank. Since I did not know where to submit
the complaint, I sent it by Speedpost to their head office in
Chennai. Their law department responded within ten days apologizing
for the error and reversing the wrong entries. I also find an
improvement in the way customers are being serviced by that
particular branch.
The way forward is to use RTI.
Using RTI is very simple.
1. Go to your nearest post office and buy five postal orders of for
Rs.10 face value. Keep these for making five RTI applications.
2. If you wish to make a complaint, write down your complaint and
submit it to the Public Information Officer of the concerned
organization. (You must check whether there is a nearby Public
Information Officer or whether you should go to their Head Office
etc.)
3. Make sure that you have a photocopy of your complaint so that you
can take an acknowledgement from the office. They will normally sign
and affix a seal and a date stamp.
For more information about RTI, please visit bangaloreGiri's RTI
page which is at:
http://www.bangaloregiri.com/rti.htm
My experience in the past one year as an activist:
I have found two types of people.
Type 1: They complain about a lot of things but do nothing to
improve their situation. They are willing to send long emails of
complaint but are not willing to either come for a face-to-face
meeting of like minded activists as they are too busy nor are they
willing to make an RTI complaint themselves.
Type 2: One person I know in this category is a very active
activist. He goes to many meetings and rallies and works endlessly
for the cause of RTI. However his motivation is ego based; people
must say that he is great, that they got succour because of his
efforts. The moment he sees that activities are being broad based
(such as BangaloreGiri giving useful information to the people and
making them stand up to fight their own cause) he backs out because
then he will get no personal credit.
The fact of the matter is that you do not need anyone's help in this
matter. You can get immediate results by using RTI.
You have outlined various complaints below.
Why not use RTI to get an immediate and long lasting solution?
Once you have made the RTI application, email me the results that
you obtained. We would like to put this up at our website
www.bangaloregiri.com so that it will be of motivation and help to
others.
If you are interested in talking to me, my contact number is 94481
37203, and you could call me any time in the evening (6 pm -
midnight).
We can work together for a better Bangalore.
Regards,
Prakash